The Dave Ramsey Bitcoin and mortgage debate
A couple sitting on enough Bitcoin profit to clear their mortgage has reopened the fight over whether to cash out crypto gains or keep riding them — and the tax fear driving most of it is overblown.
- The wife wants to sell and own the house free and clear; the husband wants to hold because he thinks Bitcoin keeps climbing and he'd have to sell less later.
- The tax worry is smaller than it looks: coins held over a year are taxed at a flat 15% long-term gains rate, and sales can be spread over several years to stay in that bracket.
- Selling inside a year is the real trap — those gains get taxed as ordinary income, which can run far higher.
- The deeper split isn't about Bitcoin at all; it's one spouse treating a joint investment as personal, with no shared plan for retirement or the house.
- Ramsey Solutions gets criticism on two fronts here — misunderstanding how crypto gains are taxed, and insisting home prices don't crash.
Outlook: The practical path is taking some profit now, paying the house down aggressively rather than all at once, and keeping the rest invested.